Awarded by the National Scouting and Youth Service Committee to an active, alumni, advisory or honorary Brother who has made a significant contribution to the youth of their community through Scouting and/or another youth service organization and who has worked to strengthen the relationship between Alpha Phi Omega and the youth service organization at a local, regional, state and/or national level.
To be considered for the Herbert G. Horton Service to Youth Award an individual must:
| 2004 | Robert Amick | Meeker, CO | |
| 2004 | James Chandler | Cedar Grove, WI | View Bio |
| 2004 | Craig Donais | Manchester, NH | |
| 2004 | Francis Evans | Northampton, MA | |
| 2004 | Clark Israel | St Clairville, OH | View Bio |
| 2004 | Lorin Jurvis | Rockville, MD | View Bio |
| 2004 | Joseph Kuchta | N Chelmsford, MA | |
| 2004 | Michael Nathan | Tallahassee, FL | View Bio |
| 2004 | John Russell | Bethesda, MD | |
| 2004 | Milton Smith | Burlington, NJ | |
| 2004 | Thomas Strong | Bethel Park, PA | |
| 2004 | Thomas Strong | Pittsburgh , PA | |
| 2004 | Howard Wolf | Beachwood, OH | |
| 2005 | Michael Brown | Tamarac, FL | View Bio |
| 2005 | Kenneth Davis | Alexandria, VA | |
| 2005 | David O'Leary | Takoma Park, MD | |
| 2005 | Rodger Salzman | Kemmerer, WY | |
| 2006 | Barbara Anderson | Lancaster, OH | View Bio |
| 2006 | Steven Crawford | Mesa, AZ | |
| 2006 | Patrick Higgins | Alexandria, VA | View Bio |
| 2006 | Patrick Higgins | Fairborn , OH | View Bio |
| 2006 | John Howard | St. Louis, MO | |
| 2006 | Timothy Jenkins | Houghton, MI | View Bio |
| 2006 | Thomas Montgomery | Fairfield, OH | |
| 2006 | Lee Peters | Westerville, OH | View Bio |
| 2006 | William Russell | Georgetown, TX | |
| 2006 | William Russell | Georgetown, TX | |
| 2008 | David Briscoe | Little Rock, AR | |
| 2009 | William Amidon | Trumbull, CT | |
| 2009 | James Lang | Syracuse, NY | |
| 2009 | Paul Louie | Richmond, VA | View Bio |
| 2009 | Lonnie Reisinger | Springdale, AR | |
| 2009 | Michael Richardson | Manassas Park, VA | |
| 2009 | Kathryn Zibell-Flinn | Kansas City, MO | |
| 2010 | Everett Rollins | Maggie Valley, NC |